So basically the first 53 are correct, I do not have them all personally. I added Scholar and Dancer directly to the list, I'm very sure they were added in recently.
*Thanks Destinye
**I can account for 970 of the original so only one 30G is missing. Since "relic" is an original one, if it exsist its a 30, see the add on below.
The sticklers are those last four unknown. I very sure that one of those is for Gold Balistar Title. I fairly certain most of you don't have an Xbox copy of the game but for those that do or know of someone who does, if you guys know what those missing three are go ahead and post as it would be appreciated. Possible ideas: EDIT: see above
Again if this has been done sorry. I decided to post after seeing website after website being incomplete on this. It's a small annoyance to make all the damn achievements secret, if nothing else when anyone looks at the gamerscore they can't even see what you got it for unless they themselves have that unlocked as well which made trying to find those last three very difficult.
EDIT: adding this for first time readers who skip posts to see what's been happening:
Now you guys have me paranoid, like I said earlier Relic one of the few I can't personally authenticate. Is there anyone out there who can prove this one is an achievement? I have it there cause every website I've seen says it is one. Cause if there's no actual one for relic I can easily see that 40 being completion of WotG since every other expansion ends on a 40G. This one is the third from last in my list.
unlocked ones here then:
30
30 30 30 30 30 30 30 30
30 30 30 30 30 30 40 20
30
Remove 13 of those 30s for jobs, and then one more 30 for Dyna Tav. (Note: I have 7 75's hence the 13)
I think they are in order: 11 jobs 75 not dnc and sch. Then one for Dyna Tav, those are the bolded ones. So now kind of back to the beginning here because 2 of those side by side remaining 30's are dnc and sch. Since they were added in the 250 update they are just tacked on to the end. That would imply that at the very least 30 30 40 20 30 are WotG which I can't prove (the proof being that they are specifically for things in WotG itself I mean). What I can prove is that the "Relic" one is suppose to be in the initial 1000; I remember seeing it in the original list saying fuck, that's some hard shit. You know this fixes some math I was tearing my hair out over yesterday, in excel I kept getting for original Achievements 1010G. So either: Relic is in there, and it's only 30 points instead (easy cross mistake with the Assualt Rank achievement), or it's not an achievement a la those two posters and that first nonbold 30 is actually:
Ballista - FFXIclopedia - a Wikia Gaming wiki Scroll about half way down to Chevrons, it talks about an achievement there.
"XBOX 360 users: Being in possession of a Gold Ballista Chevron and talking to a title bard will grant you the option of unlocking an achievement." You must have the chevron in your Key Items for the option to appear.
That would also leave the 30 30 40 20 30 for WotG, which is 150 of the new 250 (and remember that 100 went to those 20 5's) So is anyone able to prove that ballista one? I think I'd be a happy camper if it turns out relic isn't one but that's just my opinion.
Edit of the stuff in spoiler tag: Occam's Razor says that they mixed up Capt. Rank and Relic gamerscore, and that the ballista one is actually one of the expansion 250. Also, fuck relic being worth only 30 what are they thinking?
I know the irony of saying every website is wrong with the same info, whereas info from a single source that is the lol wiki might be the correct info. So don't bother pointing that out. I simply just want to find out what these missing achievements truly are.